In a recent decision in New Dairy S.C. LLC v. City of North Charleston, the plaintiff challenged the City’s discovery responses after receiving a production of nearly 800,000 pages totaling 187 GB of data that allegedly functioned as an inaccessible document dump. The case underscores the limitations of relying on large-scale productions to satisfy discovery obligations without providing meaningful guidance to the requesting party. The District Court for the District of South Carolina granted in part and denied in part the plaintiff’s motion to compel, finding that the City improperly relied on Rule 33(d) by directing the plaintiff to broad document collections rather than providing substantive narrative responses to interrogatories. The court further rejected unsupported relevance and proportionality objections, concluding that information concerning the City’s relationship with a potential developer was relevant to the plaintiff’s claims.
The court also addressed privilege disputes arising from deficiencies in the City’s privilege log and the inadvertent disclosure of certain communications. Although the court acknowledged shortcomings in the City’s privilege practices, it declined to find a waiver of attorney-client privilege, emphasizing that privilege waiver is an exceedingly harsh sanction that generally requires unjustified delay, bad faith, or other inexcusable conduct. The court likewise refused to impose a broader waiver based on the accidental production of privileged materials. While reserving judgment on sanctions, the court directed the plaintiff to submit its costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees for camera review.
For eDiscovery teams, the decision reinforces that large-volume productions must be organized, accessible, and responsive to the actual discovery requests at issue. Producing extensive Bates ranges without identifying where responsive information can be found does not satisfy Rule 33(d) and may invite judicial intervention. The ruling highlights the importance of combining defensible production workflows with meaningful interrogatory responses, appropriately supported objections, and compliant privilege logging practices. The decision serves as a reminder that successful discovery requires more than producing data at scale. Parties must ensure that productions are usable, proportional, and tailored to the needs of the case to avoid costly disputes, fee awards, and potential sanctions.
Reach out to Chris Puente, Director of Operations at CODISCOVR. With more than 25 years of big law experience, Chris leads our eDiscovery delivery team and partners closely with legal teams and clients to develop defensible discovery strategies, implement best-practice workflows and quality controls, and manage complex matters across the full EDRM, from preservation and collection through review and production.



